Should this young tennis player and John McEnroe take the same quantity of over-the-counter medications? (Source)

Should this 12-year-old tennis player and John McEnroe take the same dosage of over-the-counter medications? (Source)

Something about this seems goofy to me. This is one of those days when I’m writing about something I know almost nothing about but have wondered about for a very long time. Over-the-counter medications typically have dosing directions that read something like this example:

Adults and children 12 years of age and older:  Take 2 tablets every 6 hours as needed. Do not take more than 8 tablets in 24 hours.

Who came up with that? Why would an average 96-pound child of twelve years of age need the same strength medication as an adult who weighs 192 pounds or 288 pounds, two or three times the weight of a 12-year-old child? Does that make any sense? Not to me.

And not that I want higher doses myself. It’s the logic of those directions that defy my person-on-the-street understanding. I weigh about twice as much as a 96-pound 12-year-old child. How can a fixed amount of medication accomplish as much in a 200-pound person as it does in a 100-pound person? In a 300-pound person?

After several attempts to find an answer online, I gave up.

If any of you can cite a documented explanation for this logic puzzle for me in the comments below, I’d appreciate it. Surely, some of you can shed light on this. Does it make sense to you? 

Advertisements